Print

Please login or register.
1 Hour 1 Day 1 Week 1 Month Forever
Login with username, password and session length

[grantis]

Hi forum

I'm looking into getting a dual G4 1.25 GHZ mac to run Mix (solely for purposes of tracking at this point, I hate the latency of LE).  888 I/O's will come with it (2).

Would I be ill advised to plan to upgrade my Mix system down the road to HD2 Accel (PCI) and think that it will run fine on my G4?  Or will I need a G5?  Will my 888 I/O's work with HD2 accel?  I can't seem to find any good literature on the topic.

Thank you!

[Iain Graham]

The 888s will work, but only through the legacy port on an HD interface.

The G4 will also work, but it'll be slow, and may not feature on Digi's supported computers list.

[E Merrill]

The g4s have horrible issues with noise (even the "quiet" ones). At this point the G5s should be cheap enough to make it worthwhile. There is also a HUGE difference in speed.


Eric

[j.hall]

are you talking about used PPC g5's?  cause they are anything but cheap new.

by noisy do you mean the machine itself is noisy?  or do they have grounding problems and make the audio noisy?  i've never heard of the latter.

my G5 isn't exactly quiet.  that's why it's back in the machine room.


if you get an adat bridge and an aurora, that can easily be migrated to an HD system and the converters sound great.

[Podgorny]

All G5s are used.
The new PowerMacs are Intel-only.

[grantis]

i guess i'm most concerned with the G4 being powerful enough.  i'd rather just get what i need now in terms of the computer, and not have to upgrade my computer and HD at the same time.

i highly doubt at G4 would cause noise in the audio, just fan noise.  G5's are only quiet if they have the liquid cooling system in them.  if not, they're just as loud as a G4.

[E Merrill]

I admit I haven't checked prices since I've had mine for a while. I assumed that G5s, being old computers, would be cheap. As far as noise, they are nowhere near as loud as the G4s. I didn't say they were quiet. I would never record with one in the room but I CAN stand to have the door to the computer closet open while I'm working. That is a HUGE difference. And the power is much, much more rewarding.

[j.hall]

looks like a dual 2gig G5 can be had for under 1k.  though you'll need more ram and a display....that's still not bad.

doesn't mix support stop at panther?

[grantis]

i'm not sure about panther.  the guy i'm looking into buying MIX from told me he had it running on Tiger, but it was WAY faster on Panther, so I just assumed that it'd be better to run it on Panther.

there-in lies my problem...if Dual 1.25 ghz G4's are roughly $400, and G5's are roughly 1k, i'd rather just get the G4 if it will run HD2 PCI.  I assumed that all Pro Tools operations run TDM and don't need the CPU's for much.  am i wrong in assuming that?

[j.hall]

just calculating wave forms, fades and running RTAS plugs to lighten the load on your HD cards.

[Jay Kadis]

MIX support does in fact end at 10.3.8 although you can run 10.3.9 if you revert to QuickTime 6.5.2.  We run an older HD1 system on an 867 MHz G4 and it works.

[Berolzheimer]

With Mix hardware you can only go up to PT v6.4.1, OS 10.3.8.  I have a single G4 867 running that configuration and it's fine, though not terribly powerful.  I also run a PT HD3 on a dual 1.25-gig G4 at PTv6.9.3 & OS 10.3.9, and it;s fine too, though again limited of course compared to an intel mac with Acccel hardware.  But I've done some fairly complex mixes with 50-60 tracks on that system successfully.

[grantis]

Quote:

The 888s will work, but only through the legacy port on an HD interface.

What is the legacy port?  Does that come "standard" ?

[Berolzheimer]

grant richard wrote on Thu, 13 December 2007 15:28

Quote: The 888s will work, but only through the legacy port on an HD interface. What is the legacy port?  Does that come "standard" ?

It's a port on the HD interfaces.  What Iain menat was that to use the 888 with PT HD it has to be plugged into the legacy port on the interface.  I hate to say it but I think a lot of the info you're looking for is available on the Digidesign website.

[grantis]

Berolzheimer wrote on Thu, 13 December 2007 18:08

grant richard wrote on Thu, 13 December 2007 15:28 Quote: The 888s will work, but only through the legacy port on an HD interface. What is the legacy port?  Does that come "standard" ? It's a port on the HD interfaces.  What Iain menat was that to use the 888 with PT HD it has to be plugged into the legacy port on the interface.  I hate to say it but I think a lot of the info you're looking for is available on the Digidesign website.

thanks!!

i just visited the digidesign site about 15 min before i read that and stumbled onto that answer, and you are correct.  thank you for the help!