R/E/P Community

R/E/P => R/E/P Archives => Budget? Budget? We Don't Got No Steekin' Budjet => Topic started by: Pingu on April 15, 2006, 04:29:05 AM

Title: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: Pingu on April 15, 2006, 04:29:05 AM
In what situations do youfind yourself eqing vocals in the way in.


Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: jetbase on April 15, 2006, 04:42:48 AM
most of the time i eq vox on the way in, at least a little. it depends what mic i'm using & also on the specific performance of the singer (as well as the song they're singing in). since, by selecting what mic & angle & space to use, i'm deciding how i want the vox to sound anyway, eq'ing is just a further part of that decision. also, when recording to analogue tape (without noise reduction) i often add a bit of top end.

cheers,
glenn
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: Dave Martin on April 15, 2006, 05:14:36 PM
Typically I use no EQ to tape.
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: Tidewater on April 15, 2006, 06:44:15 PM
Nice to do a high-pass, and even band-pass, depends on the capabilities of your eq.


M
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: Fibes on April 15, 2006, 07:24:22 PM
Dave Martin wrote on Sat, 15 April 2006 17:14

Typically I use no EQ to tape.



For vocals I use EQs but they come in the form of mics, mic placement, room treatment and as mentioned in the compression thread the almighty eq called the compressor.

During mix all bets are off but if I've done my job it'll only be minor valleys and a touch of air if the mood is right.
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: John Ivan on April 16, 2006, 03:38:21 AM
I try mics till I like the sound. If I can't get it that way, I will eq a bit. Only if I'm at a loss though.

I do high pass almost every vocal though.

I EQ toms though Smile .
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: wwittman on April 16, 2006, 12:53:36 PM
I EQ whenever it makes things sound better to me.
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: danickstr on April 16, 2006, 01:26:11 PM
due to bass proximity, i think it is definitely ok to take off bottom when close micing vox. for example, but people who are "purists" find mics with the bass already missing and then they don't "eq".
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: Pingu on April 16, 2006, 01:58:35 PM
When do you roll the bottom end off?

Before or after compressing?

If you did use an eq and a compressor, in what order would you set them up?
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: Tidewater on April 16, 2006, 02:12:29 PM
EQ/compressor.

You don't want the compressor detecting, and over-reacting to the stuff you don't want in the first place.

The art of loading the compressor too... there is a black art, between certain pieces of gear.


M
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: Pingu on April 16, 2006, 04:21:41 PM
what about EQ = roll off bottom

then compressor, then eq to taste if needed.



How much bottom end to roll off.

Some pres have the hp switch which is normally about 80hz,

Is this too much roll off?

May be not as in the mix you night not need to have  this area fighting the rest of the mix.

But then again shouldn't the mix be built around the vocal?

Therefore should we not keep as much vocal as possible?

Also isn't the formant around this area?
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: John Ivan on April 16, 2006, 05:26:30 PM
Man, Just listen to stuff. Plug the shit in. Listen to what is coming out of the speaker's. Start turning knobs until you dig it. Or, don't turn any knobs because you already dig it. There are no rules that say to use or not use an EQ. As Mr. Wittman has pointed out. If you think EQ will sound good use it.

Just make stuff sound real good.

JI.......................................................... ....
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: maxim on April 17, 2006, 07:24:09 AM
if you don't know what you're doing, my advice is to do no irreversible activities until you get to the mix

i found it helpful to go back and muck around with the high pass settings on some tracks once in the context of the final mix

but then i don't know what i'm doing
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: danickstr on April 17, 2006, 11:31:05 AM
listen to your favorite music.  any typical singer you like who would be close mic'ed in your studio would sound boomy through off the shelf microphones.  if they backed off the mic...like magic you lose 8db of low end.  but shitty mics can't give nuance at this distance.

you can use your own voice for example by making the roll-off sound like you do in your own head.  10dB at 120 is not too much if the person is really close to the mic, but others will spit soda on their screens if they see this. they are idiots that do not understand mic proximity bass relationships.

telephonic sounding vocals are often desirable for popular music, but I like natural.  just not with bass effect.
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: Fig on April 17, 2006, 05:31:10 PM
John Ivan wrote on Sun, 16 April 2006 16:26

Man, Just listen to stuff. Plug the shit in. Listen to what is coming out of the speaker's. Start turning knobs until you dig it. Or, don't turn any knobs because you already dig it. There are no rules that say to use or not use an EQ. As Mr. Wittman has pointed out. If you think EQ will sound good use it.

Just make stuff sound real good.



Yeah c'mon,

Ping-let, if you ask one more question before trying at least ten different scenarios, I'm gonna punch you in the gut!

Your next post MUST state at least two scenarios you tried and what you liked or did not like about each one.

Now get to work!

Sheesh...

[rant]

the only audio argument older than "digi Vs. annie" is "eq before or after the compressor".

Both do different things, try them and you will know for yourself.  Ask questions on a forum and wonder forever.

At least do a search or something.

arrrrrgh!!!!  [/rant!]

Luv ya,

Fig
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: bloodstone on April 18, 2006, 01:22:40 AM
I tend to track things flat, but if I'm going to do any eq on vox tracking, it's normally going to be to add a little sweetness to the top end.  I like the 8k or 12k option on the Langevein DVC for that.  It's very forgiving.  Even maxed out in some cases.  
________________________
Dominic
Studio Wee/Cashmere Jungle Lords
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: Vertigo on April 18, 2006, 10:32:07 AM
Quote:

For vocals I use EQs but they come in the form of mics, mic placement, room treatment and as mentioned in the compression thread the almighty eq called the compressor.


Quote:

Man, Just listen to stuff. Plug the shit in. Listen to what is coming out of the speaker's. Start turning knobs until you dig it. Or, don't turn any knobs because you already dig it. There are no rules that say to use or not use an EQ. As Mr. Wittman has pointed out. If you think EQ will sound good use it.


My sentiments exactly! You just keep trying things until you hear the sound that you WANT to hear. Start with the mic - find what sounds closest to the sound you're looking for. If you're 95% of the way there but there's a little too much or too little of something and you think it will be a problem at mixdown, reach for the EQ.

-Lance
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: Fibes on April 18, 2006, 10:48:37 AM
I'm gonna go out on a limb and say that William does not get the torque wrench out immediately on vocals before trying a different mic or mic placement.

It's all relative and 95% of the way there could be 100% at mix time.

Since the vocals are usually the most important piece in the ensemble I try not to neuter them just because i can. Get them right without getting into eq phase issues at the start and you'll be better off. If you have limited mic choices and no placement is working try some eq but usually if i'm not happy the vocalist isn't happy.

BTW sometimes it's best to just throw a mic up there and get the performance. Yep, that damn performance.

Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: hargerst on April 18, 2006, 11:48:35 AM
The main reason I don't use eq while tracking vocals is that as soon as I do, it's 100% certain the singer is gonna wanna punch-in one line two weeks later, and by that time, I'll have forgotten what eq I used on the basic track.  That eliminates one big variable, and just leaves previous mic selection and placement.

Of course after two weeks have gone by, the singer has probably changed the emotion they bring to the song, so the punch-in never works, and I end up retracking the whole damn vocal anyway.
Title: Re: Tracking Vocs, why or why not to eq on the way in
Post by: wwittman on April 21, 2006, 12:32:01 AM
IF two weeks later the singer AGAIN sounds a little dull, I'll probably end up wiht the same +1 at 10k that i did two weeks before... and if not, it won't worry me.


I suppose I tend to do a QUICK little bit of fishing around for the right vocal mic (from a small group of contenders that repeatedly work well for me) and then unless it sounds "wrong" I'm not at all shy to put a bit of top in it or a bit of bottom or whatever.

That of course, doesn't mean i don't change mics, or more often ask the singer to move in or out, or go out and adjust the height to look right to me, and so on.

But if it needs some EQ I never worry about it, I just do it.

I don't have any preconception that EQ is "bad".