Maybe the second. To much revrb on the first one.
The first rythm guitar is an electric guitar umplugged and recorded with a mic?
I really don't like this for this song. If it is an acoustic guitar it sound to poor to me in both mixes.
I think that a more Beatles kind of mix will be better. Less reverb, guitars more present, voices more dry and some extreme panning will help the song.
I Like the sound of the plugged electric guitar that appear later.
Regards,
Luis Bacque.