Eh. I have a RADAR-V, I have great mics and outboard... I have an old Class-A/discrete console... I could give a shit about tape... I have a FATSO Jr. if I really need that sound.
Getting the depth and dimension to your recordings in the digital domain just means that you have to work like 9 times harder, but you don't have the print through, you don't have the problem of the tape getting the shit beat out of it as you run it over the heads and past the capstan 900,000 times, I don't have to check the alignment and azimuth every morning [or in one case/project, 14 times a day, but that was a very rare case (and also an amazing sounding project... but I digress)].
The first 24 track deck I ever bought ran me $28,000 USD... the last RADAR-V I bought ran me around $17,000... the last 24 track I bought probably ran me about $2,500- $3,000/yr. in maintenance... the RADAR-V ain't cost me jack... backing up masters on my analog deck required a second deck which added a generation to the safety masters... now it's hit a couple buttons, go out to dinner... come back from dinner, file the backup and move on.
As for shit sounding grainy and shitty... well we could blame the big time mixer dudes and hucksters that were buying and renting Sony 3324's and 3348's back in the 80's and 90's for that shit... then came the Pro-sTools warriors with their 666+222=888 boxes and "HD" rigs for even worse audio than you used to get with the fucking Sony pieces of shit [even with the Apologee converters... and you had to have the Apologee converters in your Sony decks to make them sound less like shit than the already sounded... but they were no where near as good as a modern Apogee converter... not even remotely close].
Let's not forget a lot of this was the bullshit economics of the audio industry where big time mixer dude would buy a $200k Sony deck then rent it to the project or mix for $800/day... more than doubling their $200k investment in less than 2 years!! Try doing that with a "Mutual Fund". It had nothing to do with the music, it had to do with rich dudes getting richer... much like that fucking dumbass "SPARS" codes... "DDD"; "AAD"; "ADD"; "ADHD"; "FSMe" [Fucking Spare Me"].
Lookit... the digital audio I hear most days is fine and dandy in the right hands, with the right tools. You wanna buy into the bullshit... well then the Sony decks were perfect [and there was no shortage of famous dudes renting them for large dollars from Alan Sides to George Massenburg, etc., etc., etc. who would be more than happy to tell you that the things did everything but shit ice cream]... and now "Pro-sTools HD" is the saviour of the planet... until the next great thing comes along from Shiti-Design and everyone will have to bite the $30k bullet again so their audio will even better than their perfect audio from the last revision.
I know I'm probably no better than any of these other lying fucks as the shop where I work pimps the RADAR stuff... but damn, there are some other great converter sets... Lavry makes great converters, Meitner [SP?], Weiss, some of the new Apogee stuff and Lynx stuff is pretty fucking excellent if not misused.
Analog certainly has a place and a vibe... and if you have a well maintained analog deck there really isn't anything like it... but capable techs are fewer and farther between, parts are harder and harder to find [they're mechanical beasts... parts wear out... unless you have metal milling machines and the skill to run them then you best have some spares or you're fucked!!].
They told me that digital was "perfect" since the late 70's... and then it got better every year since... well somewhere around like 2001, 2002 it got to the point of "acceptable" from my perspective... it still ain't to the point of "acceptable" to guys like Steve Albini, but for me, it's "acceptable"... or at least it's good enough to not get in the way of the emotion of the presentations I'm trying to record which is good enough for me.
Cheap assed digital [MOTU; RME; Pro-sTools; etc.] sounds like ass... then again, cheap assed analog sounded like ass too... but the Fostex and Trashcan decks of the day didn't sound nearly as shitty as the cheap assed digital crap flowing out of the Banjo Mart like flood water in Nawlins... so yeah, y'all can "miss analog" all you want... but there is some great shit happening in the digital domain as long as you evaluate it for what it is and not what it's been hyped to be.
...ah fuck... another sermon and no way to pass a collection plate.
Shoot me.