I know most people don't like questions like this, but I'm hoping to find someone with more experience than me who can help.
After 10 years of standing idle on recording any of this music going through my head, I've decided to take the plunge and give it a go. The problem is, I have so little extra money it's not funny. I don't even have a computer of my own to use yet. That gets budgeted like everything else.
I'll give the good news first. I have a good deal of electronics knowledge and experience, so I can actually take a handful of parts and build some pretty good mic pres and compressors, and maybe a decent EQ as well. In fact, I already have a bucketful of parts and PCBs that are currently begging to be used in something. That'll be a good set of winter projects for me. This includes some analog synths as well. A good start, to be sure.
Here comes the fun part.
Once I have a computer, I'll need converters. Yes, the dreaded converter question. I hate it as much as you do, but I really would like to know all of my options before finally choosing something.
Here is my plan: Track as high-quality of raw tracks as I can. During mixdown, determine what processing is or is not needed on each track, then loop those tracks out to the appropriate outboard chain. Then, those tracks will be re-recorded back into the computer. I've heard great results done using this method, even using average converters.
In order to do this, I'll need at least three outputs (a minimum of one for sending a track, and two to monitor what comes back in). I also need at least two inputs, since I find it unlikely I'll need more, since I'm not planning on recording drums (despite the fact that I'm a drummer, it would be way too difficult for me to record drums when I can't even have a kit right now, much less a good space to record in). Monitoring the input means it needs some internal routing options, which most cards provide these days.
Okay, so a two in, four out card should do. For best noise specs, the converters should be in a breakout box. This eliminates all of M-Audio's PCI range except the Delta-1010 (the breakout on the Delta 44 and 66 is purely for ease of connecting - the converters are still on the card). Their FireWire boxes are still an option, but I have no way to audition them.
I was thinking the MOTU 828-mkII would be pretty good, but it runs twice the price of what the computer will. If I can find a good one used, maybe...
In the end, I'd like a product good enough to keep a mastering engineer from laughing, or being aggravated at mastering yet another crummy job.
Since there are a lot of budget-minded people here, I'm hoping someone has some ideas I might not have thought of yet. Thank you all for your time, and for putting up with my long half-whining post.
You know, on my budget, ten years ago, I never could have considered having any kind of studio capability at all. How times have changed...
If I could keep the converter choice at around $400, I would be happy. A little more for better quality would be feasable. Again, thank you for your help.