Sahib wrote on Mon, 13 December 2004 20:29 |
fishtank wrote on Sun, 12 December 2004 18:28 |
Ryan Moore wrote on Sun, 12 December 2004 12:34 | I've FWIW - the silver seemed to sound best..the Belden the least, but not 'bad'.. RM
|
These types of statements can be dangerous. Did you actually do a double-blind study to determine that the silver sounded better?
One of the things I really love about this particular forum is Dan's policy about keeping things discussed here based on scientific fact. The audiophiles always seem to sneak in and rave about some esoteric cables etc. that *seem* to sound better or how they can *sense* something above 20 KHz.
|
I completely agree on the amount of hype that is made on cables but in terms of silver vs copper, of course silver is better as it is a better conductor than copper. Hence you do not need to see a proving formula to accept it. However, how much difference does a silver conductor make in audio frequency and how possible it is to hear that change is another matter. But I can assure you that it would make a difference.
Cemal
|
My ITT Reference Data For Radio Engineers tells me that resistively at room temperature (20 degree C)
Copper resistivity is 1.7241 Ohms-Cm X10^6.
Silver resistivity is 1.62 Ohms-Cm X10^6.
Gold resistivity is 2.44 Ohms-Cm X10^6.
Using copper as a reference, silver is about 6% lower and gold is about
41% higher resistivity for the SAME DIMENSSIONS.
In other words, increasing the cross sectional area by 6% will make copper resistivity equal to silver. In terms of diameter it translates to about 3% more diameter for the copper wire. In other words, just slightly thicker wire will more than overcome the material differences.
The reason I included gold is to expose some of the hype. In terms of resistance, gold is worse than copper. Of course you can add 41% more gold and be as good as copper, and it does cost money!!!
Again, one needs to examine the specific application. There are cases (very high frequencies) where the current “defies” the diameter of the material, and concentrates on the skin (skin effect), and coupled with long runs, one can loose a lot of energy. Such cases may call for silver coating. There cases where silver oxidation is not welcome and gold plating serves as protection, and so on.
For this post I am only taking about materials and resistivity.
Audio is low frequencies and one need not worry about skin effect. To say that silver vs copper matters, one needs to more than just assume that we are talking about the same exact dimensions. The basic question is at what point will the resistor begins to impact the signal.
At low frequencies, the simple model of the cable resistance is as if it were just a single resistor (component). We need to account for both signal and return path (2 wires, a wire and shield or what not). Say we have a 2 wire cable (signal and return). The wire used is 18 gauge annealed copper at room temperature (20 degree C). We get 6.4 ohm per 1000 feet in each direction, or a total of 12.8 Ohms round trip per 1000 feet. For a 16 gauge it is 8 ohms round trip and so on. So does it matter?
Clearly 12.8 Ohms is a hack of a lot if the load is an 8 Ohms speaker. Most of the energy would be wasted on the wire, and so we do not run 1000 feet of 18 gauge for speakers. But say the load is 10 KOhm. The loss in voltage is about .13% (0.011dB). That is for 1000 feet!
As a rule, at audio frequencies, high current cases call for attention to cable resistance. Sending say a 5V DC supply line to a 5 Ohm load will simply not work. But most audio cases have relatively high load impedance, where is no longer about resistance, and most often, as explained in my previous post, not about capacitance either.
I am not saying any cable is just as good as the other. I am saying: For most audio cases (low drive impedance, high load impedance) it is not about silver vs copper, or issues relating to resistivity. Of course I am assuming proper wiring of the audio cables, to carry only audio, and not be a part of some high frequency chassis return path or some AC power ground loop…
Everything I said changes at higher frequencies (MHz and above).
BR
Dan Lavry