[quote title=Paul Frindle wrote on Thu, 05 August 2004 02:21]
Johnny B wrote on Wed, 04 August 2004 14:28 |
There was another such episode a few years ago by some french guy called Bienvenista who reckoned he had diluted homeopathy solutions to the point where none of the original active molecules remained in the solution - but it still apparently showed action. The implication was that water has some sort of memory effect for compounds in solution that were long departed. All seemed pretty impossible to me - however the way he as investigated was pretty brash - a public ridiculing at the behest of report partially compiled by a magician of all people. Yet again - i don't doubt the guy's good faith - I mean who in their right mind would expect to pull off a con with such a bizarre and testable theory!?
|
The man's name was Dr. Jacques Benveniste. He was (is?) based in France or Switzerland, I forget which. Homeopathy is a *huge* business in Europe (and not too shabby a profit-maker here in the States, either). That might explain the 'who in their right mind' part.
In 1988 his work was published in Nature, probably most prestigious science journal around, but he couldn't replicate it under controlled conditions. Nature eventually apologized for publishing it in the first place. James Randi, the magician/professional debunker , came along during the
'replication' trial for the sensible reason that scientists rarely *expect* chicanery or sleight-of-hand , whereas magicians are well-trained to spot it.
Benveniste went on to win a couple of
IgNoble prize, and
these days is claiming that the beneficial 'memory' of an infinitesimally-diluted drug in water, can be transmitted over telephone lines. He is also, rather predicatbly, claiming that the scientific community is out to squash him.