J.Hall: Well what can I say, very muddy, totally wrong balance ... nah just kidding of course, to my ears it sounds pretty much perfect.
MGAudio (Me): First I deleted the snare sample files and then just pretty much mixed the whole thing, clean master, meaning no fx on the master (except dither, well actually not since I rendered directly to mp3). So in comparison to J.Halls mix (which I didn't try to match) my mix is a bit softer, has more highs and less bass.
T. Goodwin: I dislike the reverb very much, because it makes the mix lack in definition and makes instument sound diffuse, rather than defined and traceable. The reverber really doesn't suit the kick at all, it seems weak and doesn't really kick. The overall balance however is okay.
fullon21: The kick doesn't sound good. Balance is good.
osumosan: A touch too much reverb. Needs more stereo spread.
teleric: I don't like the raw, rattly bass in the intro,. I'd prefer it to be a bit softer (though with a song called Executioner who am I to expect softness). The Toms could have more spread, make them more gigantic in the mix. Guitars sound thin, could use more low end. But overall a very balanced clean mix (maybe too clean?, guitars kept in their own space, hence less low end in them hence thin sound, dunno). A good foundation for a good mastering.
mdifazio: More stereo. The snare doesn't sound good. The scratch/reverse fx in the break is too loud and (in its current apperance) doesn't suit the song. In one fill in the outro you can clearly hear how the snare switches its types, the snare general seems to bit of center to the left.
imdrecordings: WAY too loud for a mix.
southboundloco: Same as above, plus out of phase (get a goniometer).
beau: Could it be that the vox are a tiny bit of to the right? (Might just being me going crazy.) Could use a little bit more low end overall.
garret: I dont like the distorin on the vox. Mix is lacking some upper mids. Bass is really buzzy and the mix seems to have a rather overdriven vibe to it rather than clean.
The above only reflects my opinion. Value it as such, its just an opinion that someone has, not more, not less.