grant richard wrote on Fri, 11 April 2008 00:01 |
Quote: | hard rock is the hardest genre to mix well, IMO.
|
now, i've pondered this before. why is that? is it because there's such a preconception of what hard rock SHOULD sound like?
i dunno.
|
I think hard rock does have some preconceptions about what the sounds should be like. Certainly stuff should be "big." Stuff is usually pretty dry, too.
Hard rock is the classic 10lbs of stuff in a 5lb bag, in terms of sonic landscape. Especially these days as band try to throw in crazy instruments on top of the wall of guitars.
Its interesting that some of the best regarded hard rock records (e.g. RATM, Soundgarden, AC/DC) also tend to be more sparely arranged.
I suppose it at least partly goes back to Mutt Lang and AC/DC, where the kick drum became a primary player in the mix. Its been more of everything ever since. I think the Metallica Black album was another turning point, or at least is the big record I am aware of, that signaled the end of 80's hair metal gated cheeseverbiness.
Having watched a good friend really learn how to mix modern hard rock (see
http://www.myspace.com/afterthetragedy or
http://profile.myspace.com/index.cfm?fuseaction=user.viewpro file&friendid=2744699) over the course of a couple of years, I have picked up a lot of insights for my live sound work, and about mixing this stuff in general.
I think the two biggest lessons are: 1. the raw tones have to be really solid, and smooth; 2. make everything fit in the mix. If it takes a 15dB cut a sixth octave wide to remove a problem, then do it. Number 2 feeds number 1, if the raw tones aren't balanced they don't survive such drastic manipulation.
Another lesson, I would say, is that compressor release times really matter in hard rock. Attacks are almost always going from "fast" to "very fast" in this stuff, so the release envelope has a huge effect on the tone/bounce/movement of instruments in the track.
My friend's mastering engineer of choice also really likes an extra 5dB'ish of snare to play with in the raw mix, but that is not universal by any means. The snare in the pre-master mixes noted above will plaster your eyeballs into your skull.
Would love to hear J's thoughts on this...