I think this was kicked around on whatever works, but this seems a good thread for the archive, eh? That said;
Beyer DT770 - Great upper midrange definition w/big boomy bass, good seal for less leakage. Comfortable but hot $200-ish
Sennheiser eh2270 - good seal, very smooth and neutral if maybe a bit dull MY preferrence for tracking right now $170-ish
AKG K44 - For $20 bucks the seal is OK, real comfortable and easy to adjust, don't tangle in hair. The sound, OK but not great, but a good studio-public disposable, the $30 K55 is a bit more open sounding.
Fostex 44, sound ok, leak in mics, I borroed them a couple of yrs ago, glad i didnt buy em.