I agree guys, and use it for the seam reason in the same way. Especially young bands who haven't been in the studio much, if at all. I also made my students do it when I was lecturing. Spent a day on it and I played some stuff that's considered classic and some stuff I like too.
It's when someone brings something completely inappropriate that it can be a problem.
In the example I gave before, I was mixing a heavy rock record. 2 heavy, thick rhythm guitars, bass and drums. Solos and vocal on top.
I was given a reference with 1 accoustic guitar, bass and drums. The vibe of the playing was very different as well.
I was then asked if I could make the same space around the snare as in the reference.
Now musically, that's not close. The snare lacks that kind of space because of the arrangement, not the mix.
That's the kind of thing I mean, and I've seen it a few times.