spoon wrote on Wed, 20 September 2006 10:19 |
Would it be cleaner if people PM me for clarification and then I post those clarification as part of my original review?
And speaking of cleaner posts, should I post all the reviews in one thread or break them up?
Thanks for the input.
Regards, David
|
Thanks for the help.
(in that Jason Lee sort of sarcasm)
Here are my review notes. Some are comments on things, others are just observations...like if someone shortened a part.
REMEMBER, these comments are based on MY sense of aesthics.
Your Mileage Will Definitely Vary!
Regards,
David
ATOR -shorten first chorus edit. Nice vocals. Changed lead on chorus. Banjo in picazzo out. Edit last chorus. Changed ending. NICE MIX.
Calvin - Nice sparse begining. Bass heavy. Nice chorus, background vox comes in later (1st), shortened. Nice vocal verse, bass heavy. Nice chorus voxen (2nd). Nice bridge. Break like mine. Banjo! Nice fade idea, choppy fade.
Cerberus - Nice intro, clicks. Midrange -y gritty vox. Low verse bass. Low chorus vox, nice chorus instr. Electronic beats break, banjo. Nice outro chorus, except LOW voxen.
Chris Carter - Smashed chorus...pumping.
ChrisJ - Nice intro, beats. Vox low or EQ'd funny. Like the drum 'slop', nice drum tone. Vox distorts on fortissimos. A bit bass heavy, chorus instruments buried. Nice bridge. Electronice beats break, banjo, nice drum slop. Nice guitars on outro chorus. Nice outro FX.
Dikledoux - nice levels (vox too). Minimal growing chorus. Nice verse with piano...echo picazzo. Shortened last chorus. Electric beats break, banjo. Nice organ ending -stop. VERY NICE MIX.
iCombs - Used regular beginning. Chorus voxen too low. Verse vox low. electric beats break, banjo.
jhall - Nice vocals. Nice snare. Pumping/ducking on Chorus. Verse pumping. Electric beats break, banjo. Nice chorus voxen. Ending one outro chorus early.
Mario - Nice intro, vox. Nice drums, good chorus. Good verse, vox. Bridge piano muddys, overwhelms. Break like mine. BANJO. Good outro chorus. Extended organ outro.
Maxim - BASS HEAVY. No intro drums. Bass heavy.
Nizzle - Electric beats into, nice. Pumping chorus -shortened first one. Nice drums. Pumping chorus. Bass heavy break..low guitars. Electric break, banjo. Electric ending w/FX nice.
Randy Hansen - Too much reverb (Beg) for style?. Muddy chorus, low drums, w/banjo. Kept electronic drums in verse, real drums low. Bass low and muddy? Muddy/reverb guitar on break, acoustic to loud, levels. Electronic beats break, banjo.
Rankus - Nice intro, growly bass. Chorus voxen low, nice chorus levels. Nice verse, articulate bass. Low chorus voxen. Strange break eGuitars. Break close to mine. BANJO. Took off background vox on outro and removed one outro?. Fade out.
Rattleyour/Liam Nelson - Nice intro, vox. Nice Chorus, piano (fx -cted) over organ, bring in dist guitar line -nice, (fuzz?). Nice verse. Nice piano chorus two, w/eGuitar again. Bells on break, ok. Close break to mine, used organ here. Low eGuitars. Slightly muddy bass on chorus. Nice FX ending.
Scott Oliphant - Weird click count, nice intro. Nice chorus, good bass articulation, good piano in 2nd half. No bass on verse, not bad, by 2nd half something felt missing. Nice 2nd Chorus, again nice piano on 2nd half, organ too. Nice bridge. Loud bass break.
ShakeTheClown - Nice intro, vox. Nice Chorus, vox abit low. Verse bass abit muddy/loud. Nice bridge. Electronic beats break, banjo. Volume/pumping issues on outro chorus vox.
starscram2010 - Full intro, nice vox. Chorus has slight pump, low voxen. Nice verse, low vox. Chorus two, side -chained kick? Nice bridge. Electronic beats break, banjo. Pumping kick outro chorus, low voxen. Nice FX outro.
THP1 - Nice intro, vox. Nice chorus, very slight pumping. Nice verse, bass growl. Break nice. Electric beats break, banjo. Outro chorus nice, some pump.
TomC - Nice intro drums, too much FX on Vox. Chorus vox late, from outboard processing? Nice chorus. No background vox on Chorus. Bridge nice, late vox. Break like mine. BANJO! Nice organ outro w/mandolins.
UnderTow - Nice intro, bass heavy. Good chorus, lots of Voxen FX, uses banjo. Verse vox, low or bass too loud. Nice 2nd chorus, organ now. Bridge bells, lots o FX on voxen. Nice break, explosion, FX. BANJO. Nice vocal reverse RVB tail on into to last chorus. Nice play on last chorus. Fun. Good use of background vox on outro...to much FX on the same.
Urick - Nice intro, vox. Nice chorus, shortened. Nice verse. Nice 2nd chorus, shortened for bridge. Nice bridge. Nice break (cut the bridge). BANJO!
VKorehov - Regular into, nice levels vox, delay ok. Muddy/pumpy kick on chorus, bass dissappears, no background vox. Muddy sustained bass on verse. Pumping 2nd chorus. Bridge with no drums, strange. Electric beats break. BANJO!! Nice bass before last chorus. Wholly pumping kick.
Volthouse - Smashed, dullish vox, bass a bit heavy on into. Chorus nice, vox smashed. Bass a bit heavy. Overall sonics abit dark, veiled. Nice fade out, abit erratic at the end.