I would imagine that unless it is specifically requested, the tape machine is not rowed out of the corner or you booked the wrong room for tape. Having said that, I still advance the notion that if tape is done right, tape has an 'bonding' & 'sweetening' effect on the recording that is hard to walk past if you are listening. As most of us can, I can identify a good analog tape recording, with everything else being equal, fairly easy and make very positive comments on said recording. I am 60 years of age so I am from the old analog/tape world but I do agree that digital offers features that are unmatched when comparing to other formats.
BTW: I am not real sure, if humans will actually enjoy 'pure' natural sounding recordings (what ever that is) as they might sound boring. There are many. many sound-changing influences on the actual sound source. Sound capturing & reproducing devices are 'trendy' as well. Again, listen to your ears and your taste, and hope, others have similar ears and taste. Isn't that what makes artists, engineers and producers a brand name? It's not necessarily right or wrong or better or best, but a joining of similar taste within a given trend and current state of the technology. Having rambled on, I do agree that sound quality matters. And, oh yea, what about the song. A great song works regardless of the technology.
Anyways . . . I miss tape or should I say, I miss the sound of tape, as tape can be a pain in the a..! But, I do wish I had a new 1/2" stereo tape machine.
Take care,
William