Over time, gear choice becomes more important or, at least that was the case for me and still is the case as I grow.. At first, my rig was low end Analog and a bunch of typical dynamic mics and a few condensers of varying shapes and sizes.A few time based efx and a couple comps. 8 tracks..
Well,I learned to use this stuff to get sounds and used it for a long time. As time moved on, my recordings got better and better thanks to better use of the gear I had and the bands got better too,{that's the big one right there.}
The rig I have now is "better"in some ways and I'm just now getting to the point where I feel I'm reaching the end of what I can get out of it sound wise.
So, to me, it's always the quality of the song,players and vibe in the room that is more important than the gear.
Having said that, you do end up digging certain pieces of gear over others for certain task's. You find that this corner of the room is great for this amp or that and you find that this or that comp is great on most bass sounds.
The bottom line for me is getting good at using what you have and as you grow, start looking for sounds. This means gear sometimes.
I would much rather record a great band with a Mackie and a bunch of 57's than a shitty band at Steve's or Harvey's or JJ's place,right?
So, you can sort of answer your own question to some degree. Do you find certain gear works on certain things when you record? It could be that you like to put a 57 at one angle instead of another for high pitched snares or, you like one delay over another on bright guitar solo's. This all happens over time and before you really give it much outside thought. {you just do it and follow your ear's}
Hey, I have an old four channel limiter that is by any standard, sort of a pile of shit . I wont even say the name because you will all make fun of me
but, my kick snare thing has not been the same since.
It's about growth, over time..
JI...........................