you can like or not like whatever you want, your opinion and taste in music and production are as valid as anyone elses.
the only problem is that your developing a slight disdain for what it is we all believe in around here. most of the people in this forum not only LOVE indie rock as an artform and an extension of their lives (sometime it IS their life) we also have no ambition to sell 50 million records.
to it's own detriment, RRoT (and many, many other bands) are creating art for the sole sake of self enjoyment, exploration, fullfillment, and for the sake of the art itself. as over indulgent as that may seem, it's what we do, and it's what we want to do......and it's what we love.
would anyone of us take commercial sucess? you bet we would.
would we compromise our control and creative direction for said commercial sucess? i highly doubt it.
the underground rock scene is all about fans coming to you, not about you going to the fans.