jimmyjazz wrote on Sun, 20 November 2005 21:02 |
Mixerman wrote on Sun, 20 November 2005 23:02 |
Rail Jon Rogut wrote on Sun, 20 November 2005 19:58 | 1) I'm only in if you can succefully identify the RADAR and Pro Tools sound files.
2) I'll only do the test in a room/facility I trust.
Rail
|
Then you're out.
I knew you didn't have the balls.
|
Let me speak for myself and myself only, although I have heard similar thoughts from several semipro and pro engineers in the past 12 hours:
You are destroying whatever rep you had amongst many of those who are aware of what is going on here.
Ease up, man.
You had the audacity to bitch about "hedging" before the Chicago test even occured, but now you're scheduling another "test" because you don't like the results which are coming to light?
|
The test was a debacle. Too many people. Too many tests. Too many files to compare. No way of knowing what the holy grail is in the blind comparisons. I'm still going to listen to them, but I have to check them out in a studio, tomorrow.
I'll say it again. I've demonstrated this problem a dozen times, without fail. I am merely asking, that we organize a room full of professionals, and that the two internet posters most critical of my claims come to that test and participate. All I'm getting thus far are ultimatums and muddying of the waters. I'm not going to play that game. All I want to know is who is in, and who is out.
Currently, we have John Van Nest, Robert Hoffman, Randy Nicklaus, David Hecht, Bryan Jackson, and possibly Terry Manning.
If the majority of these professionals do not agree with me. that there is a significatn and obvious lopping of the low end, then I'll come on the interent and post a letter stating that I was wrong. What more could we ask for, right?
I think you're right. I've been slightly over the top. For that I apologize. Rail, whether you participate or not, you have balls.
Anyone else here in LA who wants to participate, sign up here. I'm not going to let this get too big. 10 max. So sign up, and I'll make it happen. Might have to be in January to accomodate that many people, but hell, it's been three years, What's another month or two, right?
Quote: |
Give me a fucking break. I wouldn't trust you to run a scientific test if my life depended on it. You're in WAY too deep to do this thing right.
Good grief.
|
Would you like to come? This is precisely why I want Rail involved. I'd even be comfortable if he conducted the test.
Mixerman