Harv, I'm in Ohio
More information as requested:
The room is 9w x 11L x 8h. I have LENRD bass traps floor to ceiling in all 4 corners and across the back wall/ceiling. Most of the front 30% has absorbtion as well as 2x2 panels at all first reflection points not already treated including the ceiling. I have a diffusor array on the back wall. Floor is carpeted.
Monitors are Alesis M1 Actives. Pre's are GT Bricks and Mackie VLZ
Mics I have tried in my room not including what I own are an AT4033a and a couple different CAD mics(Don't remember the models) I borrowed from my drummer. Things I have tried in various places include Studio Projects B1, Shure KSM27, AKG C3000, Rode NT1A, AT4050, U87, AKG414, CAD 3000. I'm sure I am forgetting a few as well.
The U87 is just a classic and easily recognized sound but out of my price range. The 414 would take longer but would be a possibility. The different variations both current and past make that one more difficult to sort out though.
Overlooking the U87 and the 414 for the moment, the NT1A, the SP B1, and the AT mics were the slight favorites out of the group. The SP really surprised me but all of them are perfectly usable mics. This is why I thought I may may have lost a little perspective. The mics in this range had differences but weren't night and day. I was concerned that I was even more tone deaf than I thought!
I definitely heard a very noticable difference between the 87 and the rest) but other than that the differences were a lot more subtle. Must have been a slow day at the store I guess, I got to blind test a few mics and picked the 87 out blind as the far superior mic of the group. Clear why its a standard.