Both are kind of in the same league..
I would go the latter, which is Soundcraft. I have had experience with both, and Soundcraft has always come on top.
I still own my favourite Behringer box, the EDISON.. magic machine. But, other than that… nothing.
Saying all that, to be fair.. Behringer has improved by leaps and bounds, and make so many things, and somewhat good quality for the pricing etc.. So, I wouldn’t put it past somebody to go gaga over Behringer products, as they have been improving, sound wise and quality wise too.
If it weren’t mixers you were looking for, I would have said Behringer boxes, but, the Soundcraft mixers have good British styled EQ’s that I am fond of, and are easy to use and great sounding..
Hope.. this helped.